Despite Missing Playoffs, Colts Retain Steichen & Ballard for 2025
The Indianapolis Colts shocked the NFL world with an unexpected decision: team owner Jim Irsay has opted to retain both head coach Shane Steichen and general manager Chris Ballard for the 2025 season. This announcement has sparked considerable debate, with many questioning whether this move reflects a commitment to stability or a reluctance to make necessary changes.
Falling Short of Expectations
Heading into the 2024 season, Indianapolis had its sights set on a postseason berth, especially with quarterback Anthony Richardson showing promise in his rookie year. However, a combination of injuries, inconsistent play, and stiff competition in the AFC South kept them from reaching that goal.
Richardson’s growth remained a key storyline throughout the season. While he flashed potential, his struggles with decision-making and durability raised concerns. Given Steichen’s reputation as an offensive innovator, Irsay’s decision to stick with him suggests the franchise believes continuity will be beneficial for Richardson’s development moving forward.
Ballard’s Tenure Extends Amid Mixed Reviews
Chris Ballard’s future as the Colts’ general manager has been a widely debated topic. Since stepping into the role in 2017, he has earned praise for his ability to draft talented players—bringing in stars like Quenton Nelson, Jonathan Taylor, and Michael Pittman Jr.—but has also been criticized for his inability to secure a long-term quarterback until the team drafted Richardson.
Despite keeping the Colts competitive, Ballard has yet to build a true championship contender. Irsay’s decision to retain him suggests the owner still believes in Ballard’s roster-building approach. However, fans’ patience is running thin, and results will be expected in 2025.
Irsay’s Commitment to Stability
Jim Irsay has built a reputation for making bold and sometimes unpredictable moves. His choice to stick with Steichen and Ballard, despite the team’s playoff struggles, aligns with his preference for continuity over constant upheaval.
Irsay has seen firsthand how frequent coaching and quarterback changes can disrupt a team’s progress. By maintaining the current leadership structure, he is signaling his belief that long-term development is more important than immediate reactions. However, this approach comes with risks—another disappointing season in 2025 could force Irsay to make drastic changes.
What Lies Ahead for the Colts?
As they prepare for 2025, the Colts must address key weaknesses to improve their chances of reaching the playoffs. Strengthening the offensive line, adding playmakers to complement Richardson, and solidifying their defense will be top priorities. A consistent running game, led by Jonathan Taylor, will also be essential.
With the AFC remaining one of the most competitive conferences in the league, the road to the playoffs will not be easy. However, if Richardson takes a significant step forward and Steichen fine-tunes his offensive schemes, Indianapolis could prove its doubters wrong.